Choosing Saatva vs. Casper
If you’re caught in the Saatva vs Casper mattress dilemma, both beds are popular, supportive, and manufactured by reputable brands.
In terms of feel, though, these mattresses are quite different. We’ll look at the similarities first before probing the differences. You can also check their individual reviews by searching for Saatva Review or Casper Review.
Similarities
- Memory Foam: The Saatva is a traditional innerspring while the Casper is an all-foam mattress. Both contain memory foam for contouring and support
- Cooling: The Saatva’s breathable coils and the Casper’s top layer of open-cell foam makes both mattresses ideal for regulating temperature
Construction
Saatva vs Casper materials: We’ll check out how each of these mattresses are made next.
Saatva
- Cover: Made from 100% cotton, the soft Saatva cover is highly breathable. The foam quilting adds comfort
- Pillow top: This section is made of individually wrapped coils. You’ll get great bounciness and a feeling of sleeping on rather than in the mattress. Airflow is outstanding
- Support: The rugged steel coils and robust edge support are impressive
Verdict: The Saatva is a classic innerspring, so it’s firm, taut, and bouncy. It makes a great choice for combination sleepers.
Casper
- Cover: The blended polyester cover is soft, cozy, and removable
- Comfort: There’s a layer of latex-like foam on the top later which responds rapidly to pressure and gives immediate bounce. The open-cell design promotes airflow and leads to enviable cooling and breathability
- Contouring: The memory foam beneath this comfort layer is much slower responding to pressure lending to pressure relief and powerful contouring
- Transitional layer: The zoned support is comprised of different types of polyfoam giving lift to the hips and some relief for the shoulders
- Base: The base is composed of heavy-grade polyfoam giving the Casper its structure
Verdict: A mixture of foams makes the Casper a good choice for a wide variety of sleepers. The Zoned Support system efficiently relieves pressure at the hips and shoulders.
How Do Innerspring and Memory Foam Mattresses Differ?
Saatva vs Casper: These mattresses each feel quite different.
The Casper takes the all-foam approach to comfort. Using high-density polyfoam along with memory foam and latex, you get a nice balance between support and pressure relief. Back and side combination sleepers will find this a very comfortable sleeping surface.
The Saatva, by contrast, is a classic innerspring mattress. Bouncy and firm, you don’t get the same amount of pressure relief, but you’ll be rewarded with bundles of support. This mattress works well for back or stomach sleepers. Side sleepers might find the Saatva too firm.
How do These Mattresses Feel?
How these mattresses feel will depend on your size, body shape, weight, and sleeping position.
That said, we can still give you a generalized feel for the Saatva vs Casper across the categories that count.
Saatva vs Casper: Firmness
Casper
This mattress is rated 7 on the firmness scale, a notch above medium-firm. This translates to effective pressure relief and support. The Zoned Support System is first class and gives you a feeling of sleeping on the mattress. This works especially well for side sleepers.
Saatva
The Saatva is rated 6.5 on the firmness scale (medium-firm).
The coil-on coil build gives the Saatva an even firmer feel than the above rating would suggest.
The above relates to the Luxury Firm Saatva. This mattress is also available as Plush Soft (3 to 5) and Firm (8) if you prefer a different firmness setting.
Saatva vs Casper Alternative Models
Here’s a glimpse at the other mattresses in the Saatva vs Casper portfolios.
- Casper Wave: This is Casper’s take on a luxury mattress constructed with 5 soft foam layers
- Casper Hybrid: Rather than a polyfoam base, the hybrid gets a pocketed coil system
- Loom & Leaf: This is an all-foam bed unlike the Saatva, but it’s not a bed-in-a-box. There’s a top layer of memory foam infused with gel and great pressure relief
What Should I Buy, a Casper or Saatva Mattress?
Each of these mattresses is suited to distinct sleepers.
Combo sleepers looking for powerful pressure relief should consider the Casper. The balanced foam leads to a comfortable sleeping surface with plenty of mobility and sufficient contouring.
The bouncy and taut Saatva, on the other hand, is a neat choice for stomach and side sleepers. The innerspring feel might not work well for anyone with pain in the hips or shoulders. The mattress could support lower back pain, though.
In terms of Saatva vs Casper pricing, there’s little to choose between these mattresses.
FAQs
How is the Casper mattress constructed?
The Casper mattress has 4 layers. The top layer is a foam similar to latex. Beneath this comes a memory foam later then the Zoned Support system and the base featuring rugged, dense polyfoam.
How is the Saatva mattress constructed?
The Saatva mattress has 2 layers. The first layer is memory foam with a pillow top and wrapped coils. The second later is made from foam and steel coils.
How are the Saatva vs Casper mattresses similar?
Both mattresses have memory foam for great contouring support. They also both offer great temperature regulation.
Saatva vs Casper
Saatva vs Casper Review
Each of these mattresses is suited to distinct sleepers. Combo sleepers looking for powerful pressure relief should consider the Casper. The balanced foam leads to a comfortable sleeping surface with plenty of mobility and sufficient contouring. The bouncy and taut Saatva, on the other hands, is a neat choice for stomach and side sleepers. The innerspring feel might not work well for anyone with pain in the hips or shoulders. The mattress could support lower back pain, though. In terms of pricing, there’s little to choose between these mattresses.
